Wales & West Utilities v the CMA: the first judicial review challenge to a CMA price control determination appeal decision

July 23, 2026
Article posted by: Nimoy Kher, Sophie Read
In the case of R (on the application of Wales & West Utilities Ltd) v Competition and Markets Authority [2026] EWHC 99 (Admin), the Administrative Court provided clarity on the correct approach to price control determination appeals to the CMA under the Gas Act 1986.

While the judicial review challenge was ultimately dismissed by the Court, it provides guidance on areas such as the standard of review required for appeals to the CMA, the proper construction of the financing duty, and the management decisions of licensed utility operators when it comes to cost of debt allowance and tax clawbacks. As the first judicial review challenge to a price control determination appeal decision of the CMA, the case provides important precedent for future challenges of this kind. For businesses operating in the renewables and private-sector energy markets, the judgment is also a useful reminder that regulatory price-control decisions can materially affect project economics, financeability and risk allocation across the wider energy sector.

Key Acronyms used in this article

Wales & West Utilities Ltd is “WWU”.

The Competition and Markets Authority is the “CMA”.

The Gas Act 1986 is the “Act”.

The Gas and Electricity Markets Authority is “GEMA”.

The Office of Gas and Electricity Markets is “Ofgem”.

Background of the case

This case arose from a statutory price control determination appeal by WWU to the CMA following GEMA’s (as represented by Ofgem) price control determination for licensed gas distributors for the period between 1st April 2021 and 31st March 2026 (RIIO-2). Under section 23B of the Act, the CMA may allow an appeal from a decision by a regulator where it is satisfied that the decision is “wrong” on statutory grounds. While the CMA found in favour of WWU and other applicants on some grounds, it rejected the rest of WWU’s grounds of appeal. WWU subsequently applied to the Administrative Court for a judicial review of the CMA’s rejection of those grounds and consequently its decision to uphold GEMA’s price control determination on those issues. Although the case concerned gas distribution, the principles are relevant to private-sector energy businesses operating in highly regulated markets, including renewables developers and investors who need to understand how regulators, appeal bodies and courts approach financeability and regulatory discretion.

The grounds of judicial review challenge

The grounds of WWU’s challenge were that the CMA had:

Ground 1 – Failed to apply the proper standard of review when determining whether GEMA’s decision was “wrong” under s23D(4) of the Act.

Ground 2 – Failed to correctly interpret the financing duty under section 4AA(2)(b)[1] of the Act.

Grounds 3 and 4 – Erred in law in upholding GEMA’s approach to cost of debt and erred in its approach to the tax clawback appeal.

The Court’s Analysis and Decision

The Court ultimately dismissed WWU’s challenge and the reasoning in the judgment is set out below. This case was presided over by Justice Sheldon and the judgment was handed down on 22nd January 2026.

Ground 1 – The CMA’s approach to the standard of review for appeal

In relation to the first ground, WWU argued that the CMA had not applied the correct standard of review when determining whether GEMA’s decision was wrong and that, under section 23B of the Act, the CMA should have gone beyond a supervisory review to consider the merits of the appeal. However, Justice Sheldon concluded that the CMA had been correct in its assertion that it only needed to consider the merits of GEMA’s decision to the extent of their relevance to the determination of whether GEMA’s decision was “wrong” on the statutory grounds put forward by the appellant. Justice Sheldon also agreed that the appeal did not require a de novo hearing of all the information before GEMA. This is particularly relevant for energy businesses considering whether to challenge regulatory decisions: the case confirms that the appeal route is not a full re-run of the regulator’s decision-making process, but it can still require substantive engagement with whether the regulator’s approach was wrong on the statutory grounds.

However, Justice Sheldon found the CMA had set the threshold for evaluating GEMA’s decision too high. The CMA had required that the alternative approach suggested by the appellant, in this case WWU, would need to be “clearly superior” to the determination by GEMA in order for the decision by the regulator to be deemed “wrong”. Justice Sheldon considered that this approach risked affording too much deference to GEMA. Instead, the alternative approach only needed to provide “something more” than GEMA’s approach, i.e. something “materially better”, for the CMA to judge that GEMA’s decision was “wrong”. Where GEMA’s approach is as good as the alternative approaches, then GEMA’s approach should be upheld. For renewables developers and investors, this “materially better” threshold may be important when assessing whether there is a credible basis to challenge a regulatory methodology that affects allowed returns, financing assumptions or project bankability.

However, the Court determined that this point was more of an academic consideration which would be relevant for future appeals to the CMA but was not material to the outcome of this case.[2]

Ground 2 – the CMA had misconstrued the financing duty

The second ground of WWU’s challenge was that the CMA had failed to properly construe the financing duty in section 4AA(2)(b) of the Act because it did not consider that GEMA, in performing its financing duty, was required to consider individual licence holders and that it was sufficient to consider the average of all licensees.

The financing duty as set out in the judgement is below:

“Section 4AA(2)(b) of the 1986 Act provides that “In performing the duties under subsections (1B) and (1C), . . . the Authority shall have regard to… the need to secure that licence holders are able to finance the activities which are the subject of obligations imposed by” various statutory provisions.” [3]

In Justice Sheldon’s judgment, the CMA had indeed erred and the financing duty requires that there needs to be some regard to “each” licence holder’s ability to finance their activities. However, the Court found that this distinction would not have been material to the outcome of this challenge as both GEMA and the CMA had considered the individual licence holders. Therefore, WWU was not granted relief. This aspect of the judgment may be particularly relevant where a regulated energy business is seeking a decision that reflects its individual financing position, rather than a purely sector-wide or notional-company approach.

Grounds 3 & 4 – Cost of Debt Allowance and Tax Clawback

In the third ground of the challenge, WWU claimed that GEMA’s exclusion of derivatives from the cost of debt allowance was irrational and discriminatory and that the CMA had erred in upholding this approach. However, Justice Sheldon confirmed that the CMA was entitled to conclude that the use of derivatives by WWU could be excluded from GEMA’s cost of debt allowance calculation as the utilisation was a management decision by WWU and not a structural issue faced by the operator. This distinction between structural market conditions and company-specific management decisions may be relevant when considering how financing choices, hedging strategies and treasury arrangements could be treated in a regulated context.

Finally, for the fourth ground of the judicial review challenge, WWU argued that the CMA had erred in its conclusion that the inclusion of the cost of derivatives in the tax clawback by GEMA was not irrational.  Justice Sheldon judged that the CMA was entitled to reach this conclusion on the basis that this calculation was designed to claw back the tax benefits that the operators “actually gained”, which includes financing measures on which interest is charged, e.g. derivatives.

Key Takeaways

This case is important for licensed utility operators who wish to appeal the price control determination of regulators. Of most general relevance is the guidance on the standard of review by the CMA and on the financing duty under section 4AA(2)(b) of the Act. The Court asserted that the CMA had set the standard of review of price control determination appeals too high and that the appellant’s alternative approach only needed to be “materially” better for the regulator’s decision to be considered “wrong” . As for the financing duty, the Court’s judgment was that the duty required regulators to have regard to the ability of “each” licence holder to finance their activities. Additionally, regulators are entitled to make allowances for “structural” factors faced by specific operators when making price control determinations, but not management decisions within the control of the operator. For businesses in the renewables and private-sector energy markets, the judgment is a useful risk-allocation point: regulatory frameworks may recognise sector-wide or structural financing pressures, but businesses should not assume that individual financing or hedging decisions will be treated as matters for which regulatory allowances must be made.

This is the first challenge of this kind and therefore sets a precedent for future price control determination appeals brought before the CMA. The case may also be a helpful reference point for businesses active in regulated and quasi-regulated energy markets, including renewables and infrastructure businesses, where regulatory methodology, financeability assumptions and routes of challenge can influence investment decisions.

This article is for general awareness only and does not constitute legal or professional advice. The law may have changed since this page was first published. If you would like further advice and assistance in relation to any of the issues raised in this article, please contact us today by telephone or email enquiries@sharpepritchard.co.uk.

 

Share this content...

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

More articles